Debt Financing vs. Equity Financing: Which Option is Best for Your Credit Startup?

Startups need capital to launch, grow, and expand their businesses. Two common methods for raising capital are debt financing and equity financing. 

Debt financing involves borrowing money from a lender and agreeing to repay the borrowed amount plus interest over a set period of time. Equity financing, on the other hand, involves selling ownership shares or stock to investors in exchange for capital.

But what are the key differences and which is the better option for budding credit and lending startups? In this blog, we’ll take you through everything you need to know, including:

• What are debt financing and equity financing?
• What are the advantages and disadvantages of each type of financing?
• How should founders and startups consider each option?

Read on to learn what you need to know about debt financing and equity financing and the considerations you should be keeping in mind with pursuing either.

What are Debt Financing and Equity?

Before we start comparing these two kinds of financing, a couple of definitions are in order. Debt financing and equity are two common ways for startups to raise capital. Below, we’ll provide a brief overview of each type of financing before we look at the key advantages and disadvantages for startups of each funding approach. 

Debt Financing Explained

Debt financing is when a company borrows money from a lender, such as a bank or a private investor, and agrees to repay the borrowed amount plus interest over a set period of time.

With debt financing, the lender does not have any ownership or control over the company, and the borrowed funds are typically secured by the company’s assets. For startups, debt financing may be difficult to obtain because the company has little or no track record or collateral to offer as security.

Equity Financing Explained

Equity financing, on the other hand, is when a company sells ownership shares or stock to investors in exchange for capital. Notable companies that have used equity financing to scale included Uber, Airbnb, and Whole Foods.

Investors who buy equity in a company become part owners of the company and are entitled to a share of the profits. They also have the right to vote on important company decisions, such as the election of the board of directors. For startups, equity financing can be an attractive option because it does not require the company to make interest payments or repay the funds, and the investors share the risks and rewards of the business.

Key Differences Between Equity and Debt

The key difference between debt financing and equity financing is the way in which the money is raised and the terms of the financing. 

With debt financing, the company borrows money that must be repaid with interest, while with equity financing, the company sells ownership shares to investors who share in the profits and decision-making. Debt financing can be a more conservative option for startups, as it does not dilute the ownership of existing shareholders, but it can also be more restrictive and costly. Equity financing can be a riskier option, as it involves giving up ownership and control, but it can also provide greater flexibility and potential for growth. Ultimately, the choice between debt financing and equity financing depends on the company’s goals, financial situation, and risk tolerance.

As with any choice between two options, there are pros and cons to debt financing and equity financing. We’ll explore these advantages and disadvantages in detail in the next sections. 

Debt Financing and Startups

Debt financing is one of the two common ways for startups to raise funds, as it offers several advantages over equity financing. It offers a number of benefits that are favorable to startups, but also comes with a number of negatives that founders should be aware of.  It’s crucial for startups to carefully evaluate the pros and cons of debt financing before making any decisions about their financing strategy.

Advantages of Debt Financing

From the point of view of the startup, there are several advantages of debt financing:

• The startup retains ownership and control. Unlike equity financing, where the investors become part owners of the company and have a say in the decision-making process, debt financing does not require the startup to give up any ownership or control. The lenders do not have any voting rights or ownership in the company and their involvement is limited to the repayment of the loan.

• The financial obligations are fixed. With debt financing, the startup knows exactly how much it needs to repay and when which allows for better budgeting and planning. Unlike equity financing, there are no ongoing obligations to pay dividends or share profits with investors.

• Interest is tax-deductible. Interest payments made on debt financing are tax-deductible, which can result in significant tax savings for the startup.

• Startups are more likely to receive funding. Debt financing can be easier to obtain than equity financing, especially for startups that do not have a proven track record or a substantial asset base. Lenders may be willing to provide loans based on the creditworthiness of the startup or the collateral provided.

• On-time payments translate into better credit ratings. If the startup makes timely repayments on its loans, it can improve its credit rating, which can make it easier to obtain future financing or negotiate better terms.

Disadvantages of Debt Financing

While there are advantages to debt financing, there are also several disadvantages that startups should consider:

• Interest increases the cost of operating. Unlike equity financing, where the investors share in the risks and rewards of the business, debt financing requires the startup to make regular interest payments on the loan, which can be a significant expense.

• Failure to meet interest payments can sink the company. With debt financing, the startup is required to repay the loan, regardless of the success or failure of the business. This can create financial strain if the startup experiences cash flow problems or if the business does not perform as expected.

• Debt financing has a very rigid structure. Debt financing often comes with restrictive covenants and loan agreements that limit the startup’s ability to make certain decisions, such as taking on additional debt or selling assets.

• Most startups don’t have much, if any, collateral. Lenders may require the startup to provide collateral to secure the loan, which can be difficult for startups that do not have substantial assets.

• Default is a very real risk. If the startup is unable to make the required payments on the loan, it may default on the loan, which can result in legal action and damage to the startup’s credit rating.

• Debt financing has limited upside potential. Unlike equity financing, where investors share in the profits of the business, debt financing does not provide the startup with any potential for increased returns or growth.

Equity Financing and Startups

Equity financing is the other popular way for startups to raise funds, as it offers several advantages over debt financing. There are, however, drawbacks of equity financing, too. It’s just as important for founders to understand and weigh the pros and cons of equity financing before making any decisions about their financing strategy.

Advantages of Equity

On the other end of the financing spectrum is equity. For startups, there are several advantages of equity financing:

• There are no repayment obligations. Unlike debt financing, where the startup is required to repay the loan with interest, equity financing does not require the startup to make any payments. The investors share in the risks and rewards of the business and are only entitled to a return on their investment if the business is successful.

• The Startup gains access to non-monetary resources and expertise. Equity investors can bring valuable expertise, contacts, and resources to the startup, which can help the business grow and succeed. This can include industry knowledge, business acumen, and strategic advice.

• The company’s credibility is enhanced. If a startup is able to secure equity financing from reputable investors, it can increase the company’s credibility and visibility in the marketplace. This can help attract customers, employees, and future investors.

• Flexibility promotes growth. Equity financing can provide startups with greater flexibility to pursue growth opportunities, as there are no fixed repayment obligations or restrictions on the use of funds.

• There are no collateral requirements. Unlike debt financing, which may require the startup to provide collateral to secure the loan, equity financing does not require the startup to pledge any assets as security.

• The risk is shared. With equity financing, the investors share in the risks and rewards of the business. This can help align the interests of the investors and the startup, and can encourage the investors to provide ongoing support and guidance to the company.

Disadvantages of Equity

And of course, like debt financing, equity has its downsides for startups:

• Ownership is diluted. When a startup sells equity to investors, it dilutes the ownership of existing shareholders. This means that the founders and other early investors may lose control over the company and may have less influence over important decisions.

• Control is eroded or even lost. Equity investors may have a say in the decision-making process of the company, including the appointment of board members and the adoption of strategic plans. This can result in a loss of control for the founders and other early investors.

• There’s much greater potential for conflicts. Equity investors may have different goals and priorities than the startup, which can lead to conflicts over strategic direction, financial performance, and other important issues.

• Confidentiality is compromised. When a startup sells equity to investors, it may be required to disclose confidential information about the company, including financial data, business plans, and intellectual property. This can limit the company’s ability to keep sensitive information private.

• Capital comes with a high cost. Equity financing can be expensive, as investors often demand a high rate of return to compensate for the risks involved. This can result in a higher cost of capital than debt financing.

• Valuable time and effort must be invested. Raising equity financing can be a time-consuming and resource-intensive process. Startups may need to spend significant time and effort developing relationships with investors, preparing pitches and presentations, and negotiating deal terms.

Which Is the Best Option for Your Credit Startup?

The choice between debt financing and equity financing will depend on a variety of factors, including the startup’s financial situation, goals, risk tolerance, and growth prospects. Here are some key considerations for lending startups to keep in mind when choosing between debt and equity financing.

What’s your financial position? 

Startups that are cash-strapped and have limited assets may find it difficult to obtain debt financing, as lenders typically require collateral or a proven track record of revenue generation. On the other hand, startups that have a strong financial position and a proven revenue stream may be more attractive to lenders and may be able to secure favorable loan terms.

What’s the company’s growth potential? 

Startups with high growth potential may benefit more from equity financing, as it can provide them with the resources and expertise needed to scale up quickly. In contrast, startups with more modest growth prospects may be better suited to debt financing, as it allows them to obtain funding without giving up ownership or control.

What’s your risk tolerance? 

Startups that are comfortable with risk and have a high tolerance for uncertainty may be more inclined to pursue equity financing, as it involves sharing the risks and rewards of the business with investors. Startups that are more risk-averse may prefer debt financing, as it provides them with a fixed repayment schedule and predictable interest payments.

How much control do you want to have? 

Startups that value control over their business may prefer debt financing, as it does not require them to give up ownership or decision-making authority to outside investors. In contrast, startups that are comfortable with sharing control and decision-making with investors may prefer equity financing, as it can provide them with valuable resources and expertise.

How much will it cost? 

Startups should carefully consider the costs associated with both debt and equity financing, including interest rates, fees, and equity dilution. Debt financing can be less expensive in the short term, as it involves fixed interest payments, while equity financing can be more expensive in the long term, as it involves sharing profits and potentially giving up ownership.

Ultimately, the choice between debt financing and equity financing will depend on the startup’s unique circumstances and goals. It may be helpful to consult with a financial advisor or mentor who can provide guidance on the best financing options for the startup.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to choosing between debt financing and equity financing for a startup, there are several factors to consider. Debt financing allows startups to retain ownership and control, offers fixed financial obligations, and may be easier to obtain. On the other hand, equity financing provides access to non-monetary resources, enhances credibility, offers flexibility for growth, and shares risks. However, it dilutes ownership, erodes control, and can lead to conflicts. Ultimately, the decision should be based on the startup’s financial position, growth potential, risk tolerance, desired control, and cost considerations. Consulting with a financial advisor or mentor can help make an informed choice that aligns with the startup’s goals and circumstances.

Debt Financing vs. Equity Financing FAQ

Below, you will find some common questions founders have about the differences between debt financing and equity financing as well as their answers. 

What is the main difference between debt financing and equity financing?

The main difference between debt financing and equity financing is how the funds are raised and how the investor gets their return. In debt financing, a company borrows money from a lender and agrees to repay the borrowed amount plus interest over a set period of time. In equity financing, a company sells ownership shares or stock to investors in exchange for capital. The investors become part owners of the company and are entitled to a share of the profits.

Is debt financing or equity financing more risky for a startup?

Both debt financing and equity financing involve risks for startups. With debt financing, the startup has a fixed repayment obligation and must make regular interest payments. If the startup is unable to make these payments, it can result in default and damage to the company’s credit rating. With equity financing, the startup gives up ownership and control of the company, and the investors may have different goals and priorities than the startup.

What are the advantages of debt financing for startups?

The advantages of debt financing for startups include retaining ownership and control, fixed payment obligations, tax advantages, access to capital, improved credit rating, and no dilution of ownership. Debt financing can be a more conservative option for startups, as it does not dilute the ownership of existing shareholders, but it can also be more restrictive and costly.

What are the advantages of equity financing for startups?

The advantages of equity financing for startups include no repayment obligations, access to expertise and resources, increased credibility, flexibility, no collateral requirements, and shared risk. Equity financing can be an attractive option for startups that are seeking to grow their business, build credibility, and access valuable resources and expertise. However, it does involve giving up ownership and control of the business.

Which is better for startups: debt financing or equity financing?

The choice between debt financing and equity financing depends on a variety of factors, including the startup’s financial situation, goals, risk tolerance, and growth prospects. Debt financing can be an attractive option for startups that want to raise capital without giving up ownership or control of their company, while equity financing can provide startups with access to capital, expertise, and resources. Startups should carefully consider their unique circumstances and goals before deciding which financing option is best for them.

Frank Gogol

A seasoned SEO expert, Frank has a long history of working with and for startups. Starting in mid-2018, Frank served as the SEO Strategist for Stilt, a fintech startup that provided fair loans for immigrants in the US and other underserved markets. While with the company, he scaled site traffic from zero to more than 1.5 million unique visits per month, driving the bulk of the company’s lead generation until it was acquired by J.G. Wentworth in December 2022. As employee #5 at Stilt, Frank was witness to, and part of, the successful building and sale of a fintech company, uniquely positioning him to create content for founders about all things startups.

See author's posts